Courtesy: KVC ProductionsReview: Melcow Pondicherry
Story
Performances
Comedy
★½ · A bachelor trip, an old flame and a ghost, all fumbled. A muddled, mean-spirited comedy in which Balu Varghese is the only reason to stay.
By Bolly Bourse desk
Melcow Pondicherry should have been an easy win: a group of college friends, a bachelor trip to Pondicherry, a love story from the past and a ghost for good measure. Nikhil Mohan's debut, which opened on 13 November, manages to fumble almost all of it. The reviews have been among the harshest of the month for a Malayalam film.
The story so far
Melvi flies home from Dubai for a bachelor trip with his old college gang. It soon turns out that he is broke and lying about it. He slips away to his old college to meet a former sweetheart, and the reunion turns into a ghost story.

The idea has promise. A man who has lied to everyone about his life returns to the place where he was last happy, and finds that the past is not as he left it. A sharper film could have made that both funny and sad.
The performances
Balu Varghese, as Vipin, is the film's one bright spot. He handles the comedy well and gets most of its genuine laughs. Arjun Ashokan, a fine actor in other films, is stuck with a hero who is selfish and very hard to like, and Althaf Salim does what he can as Vinod.
Sanoop Thykoodam, who also wrote the film, appears among the gang, and the friends' easy rapport is the one thing that feels real. In the early scenes, when the gang is simply catching up, the film has a loose, likeable energy.
The craft
The background score is lively, and there are a few scenes, mostly in the first half, where the gang's banter works. Beyond that, the film looks and feels like a stretched-out short film.

The Pondicherry of the title is barely used, and the college, where the ghost story plays out, could be anywhere. For a film named after a place, it has remarkably little sense of it. The music by Electronic Kili is the most modern thing about it.
Where it stumbles
The script cannot decide what it wants to be. It is a buddy comedy, a romance and a horror film in turn, and it is not good at any of them. The supernatural idea is underdeveloped, the editing has continuity slips, and the gang's harassment of women is played for laughs in a way that has dated badly.
Above all, it is hard to spend two hours with a hero who lies to his friends, uses the people around him and is never really asked to answer for it. Comedies about badly behaved men can work, but only if the film sees them clearly. This one seems to like Melvi more than he deserves.
A ghost it does not know what to do with.
The ghost, when it finally arrives, feels borrowed from a different film, and the film does not seem to know what to do with it either.
How it opened
Melcow Pondicherry made ₹0.75 crore net in its first week on our board, falling from ₹0.25 crore on day one to almost nothing by the seventh. Word of mouth, clearly, was not on its side.
Watch the trailerMelcow PondicherryThe verdict
Melcow Pondicherry is a muddled, mean-spirited comedy with a ghost it does not know what to do with. Balu Varghese is the only reason to stay. ★½, skip it.
Arjun Ashokan and Balu Varghese have both been far better elsewhere, and deserve to be again.
Directed by Nikhil Mohan, Melcow Pondicherry is in cinemas now.
Bolly Bourse Newsbollybourse.com
More from Bolly Bourse News



Hoichoi
Sun NXT
Prime Video