Courtesy: Paramount PicturesReview: Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol
Story
Performances
Craft
★★½ · Ti West's grimy, gothic Scrooge has frightening spirits and superb design, and a divisive Johnny Depp. Handsome, but too safe to stand out.
By Bolly Bourse desk
A Christmas Carol has been filmed so many times that any new version has to answer a simple question: why this one, and why now? Ti West, a director best known for horror, has an answer of sorts. His Ebenezer, which reached Indian cinemas on 20 November after a premiere in New York on 1 November, is the grimiest and most frightening version in years. Whether that is enough is another matter.
The story so far
West keeps Dickens largely intact. Ebenezer Scrooge, the coldest man in London, is warned by the ghost of his old partner, Jacob Marley, and then visited by three spirits who show him his past, his present and the future that waits for him if he does not change.

What changes is the texture. This London is filthy, dark and dangerous, and the spirits are frightening rather than whimsical.
It is the version of the story that has always been hiding in Dickens: a ghost story told at Christmas, meant to scare its readers into kindness.
The performances
Johnny Depp's Scrooge divides opinion. Some will enjoy a lively, theatrical villain; more will find him a mannered caricature, so cartoonish that his redemption is hard to believe. Ian McKellen makes a memorable Marley, and Rupert Grint is a decent Bob Cratchit.

The spirits get the warmest notices. Andrea Riseborough is genuinely unsettling as the Ghost of Christmas Past, and Tramell Tillman's gruff Ghost of Christmas Present is the film's most original idea.
Daisy Ridley appears too, and the supporting players, clerks, beggars and party guests, make Victorian London feel crowded and alive. Rupert Grint's Cratchit is warm without being saintly, and the scenes in his crowded home are among the film's few moments of comfort.
The craft
Eve Stewart's production design and Checco Varese's sooty photography are superb: you can almost smell the coal smoke. The practical effects are handsome, and the horror touches are well judged for a story that has always had a ghost at its heart.

Tyler Bates's score leans into the gloom, and West stages the visits of the three spirits as set pieces, each with its own look and its own kind of fear.
You can almost smell the coal smoke.
Where it stumbles
For all its texture, the film plays too safe to stand out from the many versions before it. It is too frightening for small children and too familiar for adults, and the horror and comedy never quite blend. The new dialogue falls short of Dickens's own, and at close to two hours it drags. Above all, it does not move the heart the way the best versions do.
The ending, the Christmas morning that every version builds to, should feel like sunlight after a long night; here it feels like a formality.
How it opened
In India it is a small English release, with ₹0.11 crore net on its first day on our board. It arrived in a crowded week, and Christmas is still a month away.
Watch the trailerEbenezer: A Christmas CarolThe verdict
Ebenezer is a handsome, gothic retelling with frightening spirits and a divisive Johnny Depp. Worth a look for the craft, but the older versions are still the ones to watch at Christmas. ★★½, worth a watch.
Families with young children should note that this is a genuinely frightening version, closer to a horror film than a holiday treat. For older viewers who love the story, it is worth seeing once on a big screen, for the look alone.
Directed by Ti West for Paramount Pictures, Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol is in cinemas now.
Bolly Bourse Newsbollybourse.com
More from Bolly Bourse News



Hoichoi
Sun NXT
Prime Video